Showing posts with label EL James. Show all posts
Showing posts with label EL James. Show all posts

Sunday, 22 March 2015

"I concentrate on my bagel"

Due to it being the perfect occasion for a dubious dating decision, Valentine's Day was chosen as the day to release the cinematic adaptation of Fifty Shades of Grey. The adult-only erotic blockbuster has broken box office records, taking $85million dollars in its opening weekend and comfortably knocking the previous erotic blockbuster, The SpongeBob SquarePants Movie: Sponge Out of Water, off the top spot. Christian Grey is all about the money, of course, as well as feeding the world and subjugating women monogamously, but what said the critics and the real critics, members of the public? Receipts in the United States dropped by seventy-five per cent in its second week of release, suggesting word-of-mouth had been unhelpful. Reviews, meanwhile, have been vitriolic, but the filmmakers might have expected this, especially when considering how bad the film they made turned out to be. Despite this drop, the $23.4million earned at the U.S. box office was enough to keep the movie at the top of the charts. Sequels and spin-offs are inevitable and given how abruptly the first film finishes, there should be no doubt that the audience's punishment is far from complete.

Fifty Shades of Grey: The Movie scores a twenty-five per cent approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes. Early indications suggest this is twenty-five per cent higher than initial predictions. Many critics have praised the film for not being the book, and this appears to be the movie's main strength. The major failings of Fifty Shades of Grey: The Novel were found in the writing of E.L. James. The book was long, the plotting was tedious, the sex scenes were gratuitous, the inner goddess interior monologues were infuriating and the lengthy descriptions of the hero's perfection exhausted the reader's patience. The new and exciting medium of film alleviates these problems by swapping prose for images. Who needs to hear how beautiful Christian Grey is when director Sam Taylor-Wood fills her frames with Jamie Dornan staring intensely at the middle distance, looking all handsome? Who needs to be told of Grey's opulence when behind Jamie Dornan is proof in the form of product placement? Who needs to know what Ana Steele thinks? The screenplay pares down James' five-hundred pages into two hours of moving pictures, thus removing a huge number of offending words. The remaining offending words are still offensive, but there are fewer of them.

In her review for Sight & Sound, Jane Giles begins by listing classic romances. 'Like Cinderella, Bluebeard, Pygmalion or Twilight, (Fifty Shades) is a romantic fantasy and a fairytale, a story of sexual awakening in which the innocent heroine’s inherent strengths allow her to battle monsters, in this case capitalism and a male sexuality twice-warped by childhood abuse and adolescent manipulation.' The critics have joined the filmmakers in the psychological nightmare that is attempting to find subtext in softcore titillation. Capitalism is a monster humankind cannot fight with naïve virgins alone. Still, Ana doesn't so much fight oppressive economic models as she does admire all that they buy and then marries a billionaire for a life of financial comfort. The main antagonist Ana faces, besides the crazed stalkers, ex-girlfriends, parents, college students and mechanical malfunction, is male sexuality. She does this with a straightforward ease most becoming of how women behave in erotic novels. She asks Christian to change, which he does because the narrative requires it. Then she asks him to change again, in much the same way as before, except this time he refuses, again because the narrative requires it.

Critics have noted that the filmmakers were constricted by the source material and the author's sway over all elements of the process. Giles admits, 'One suspects that Taylor-Johnson was never free even to push at the edges of sexual representation, and the film’s lack of explicit imagery and grit is one of its disappointments.' Following a similar conclusion Margot Harrison at Seven Days noted, 'A more adventurous writer and director could have turned this twisted fairy tale into a full-fledged surreal fantasy, using its inconsistencies as assets. But James, who wielded considerable control over this production, surely wouldn't have given her OK to such escapades.' E.L. James is not solely to blame for wanting the film adaptation of her novel to have similarities with what she wrote. Audiences, too, were keen that their favourite scenes were loyally translated to the big screen. Had a writing team featuring Kelly Marcel, Patrick Marber and James herself deviated from the source material, changing characters or cutting those long, redundant sequences that readers loved, the disapproval of the viewers would have been felt in box-office figures. Fortunately, Taylor-Wood stayed true to that classic scene where Ana sits at her new laptop and tries to think of something clever to write.

Speaking of which, for there to be cheap sex there must be alternatives in terms of price; expensive, modest, reasonable, bargain. There are possibly others. Fifty Shades of Grey falls across categories. On the one hand, it is sleazy exploitation, but that hand is gloved in decadence as designed by Armani. This presents an unobtainable vision of beauty and affluence to an audience just wanting to be aroused by an acceptable pornographification of status. To the uninitiated Fifty Shades may appear to be a subversive twist on the fairytale romance between prince and pauper, but it instead belongs to the Solicititilation tales of Mills & Boon. Ana refuses money from her lover-cum-owner, and his extravagant gifts are considered loans. She does not want Christian for his wealth and life of luxury, preferring to pretend there is her ideal man behind the emotional sterility and violence. His violence is not real violence, of course, but rather the fluffy kind of subjugation that is both pleasurable and sensitively-undertaken. Ana concludes her story victorious, married to the billionaire and with all the beauty and affluence that entails.

When an example of female empowerment is offered, where better to look for insightful critique than Playboy magazine? Stephen Rebello has few kind words. 'This gift to the world of schlock cinema tries valiantly to elevate the Twilight fan fiction-inspired source material to a level of melodrama worthy of ‘60s stuff like A Summer Place or Strangers When We Meet. It sometimes succeeds but just as often it sloshes around in a bubble bath of high camp a la 9 ½ Weeks.' Despite this less than impressive beginning, Rebello does admit that there are positives to be found in the glossy, fetishistic look of a perfume commercial, the film's lurid convictions and fifteen minutes of sex scenes so timid no one should be forced to shift awkwardly in front of confounded grandparents. 'The plot is as simple as its sexual politics are muddled,' he adds. Readers might have assumed this from their memories of reading, but fans of Romance fiction who missed Fifty Shades will assume this as well.

As to be expected from a Playboy article, the review ends a criticism that could just as easily be thrown back in its direction, with the sexes reversed. 'It floats in a female wish-fulfilment world of ridiculously handsome, chiseled dudes so engorged with desire that they whisk away average-looking virgins on their self-piloted private jets to their lavish penthouses featuring walk-in closets the size of Texas, drawers lined with an endless assortment of grey silk ties and, just for fun, a secret torture chamber.' Nothing says female wish-fulfilment quite like a lack of colour in decorative accessories, and yet, as we all know, there are only fifty shades of grey tie and that hardly constitutes an endless assortment. Despite this oversight, Rebello's review is consistent with those who have felt the need to weigh in on Fifty Shades. The overwhelming critical disdain was written resignedly, as nothing would stop the money train from pulling into every station. The Turner prize-winning director, the Academy Award-nominated co-scribe and the Oscar-winning producers combined their high-brow credentials for the veneer of artistic credibility, but their movie was always going to escape the box-office poison of expert opinion.

Tuesday, 21 May 2013

“Anticipation runs bubbling like soda through my veins”

In the continuing aftermath of Fifty Shades of Grey's existence numerous writers and bloggers, similar to Bewildered Heart but with a much wider audience, used the opportunity to apply their education and thinking to a subject that people were interested in. This allowed for endless discussions on previously niche topics such as women and books. As noted on this very weblog, a striking opinion came from Newsweek reporter Katie Roiphe and the reaction to her essay was dismayed and largely critical, the natural response to a controversial viewpoint written to keep journalism alive for another week. Many found fault in the central argument, but if women don't enjoy submission fantasies such as the Fifty Shades trilogy because they yearn for momentary escape from economic participation and social equality then why would anyone subject themselves to EL James' prose, with the obvious exception of literary masochists and websites about romance fiction that desperately need attention?

In highlighting the fall-out let us begin with a Dana Goldstein article winningly entitled On Feminism and Sadomasochistic Sex, which appeared on The Nation mere days after Roiphe's publication. 'Taboo-breaking sex is culturally prevalent right now not because of macroeconomic trends like the decimation of the male manufacturing sector but because we live in an age in which all sorts of sexual practices are incredibly visible and talked about,' begins Goldstein, setting the scene in which Fifty Shades struck with brutal, yet erotic, gusto. Naturally, the novel concerned does not feature taboo-breaking sex, but Goldstein has larger issues on her mind. If history has taught us one thing it is that people have always been interested in sadomasochism. 'Why assume, as Roiphe seems to, that some authoritative brand of feminism was ever supposed to lead to human beings losing their curiosity about power play during sex?' Thus the tale of Christian Grey's penchant for whips is nothing new, and as Goldstein concludes, 'Sadomasochism is problematic if one partner is doing it just to please the other and feels hurt by it.' Yes, this certainly might cause trouble, but fortunately Dana is discussing Fifty Shades of Grey and so the thought passes without comment.

Goldstein and Laurie Penny take issue with Roiphe for citing two examples, the other being television show Girls, and claiming there to be a trend. Penny's main contention is that the media  fixates on this single female perversion at the expense of all others, but while this may contextualise Roiphe's critique, it does little to address the novel or its success. The examples of de Sade, Swinburne, Anais Nin, Anne Desclos and Anne Rice should have been ample warning of EL James' over-achievement, but it will do little to reassure Dr. Drew Pinksy, and a handful of historical anecdotes is hardly enough to counter Roiphe's assertion of a disturbing phenomenon. Several publishing houses, Mills & Boon included, have sought to cash-in, with plenty of authors seeing their work packaged and sold as the new Fifty Shades. Do the burgeoning careers of Indigo Bloom, Vina Jackson, Eve Berlin, Sadie Matthews, Marina Anderson, Sarah Fisher, L. Marie Adeline and Evie Blake, to name but nine, suggest cynical exploitation, a trend or a combination of the two?

Rebecca Newman, GQ's sex columnist and thus an authority on male dysfunction, takes the popular view that Feminism allows for all forms of sexual predilection. 'Done properly, BDSM is ying yang — you are surrendering certain freedoms on the understanding that you are turned on by it. Can a feminist be submissive? If it is consensual, safe, in a loving relationship, then of course.' Naturally, this offers a rather limited appreciation of feminism, insinuating that paraphilias can only be indulged within the confines of a committed partnership, but it also completely ignores Fifty Shades of Grey, as if the novel is merely a window into a related subject and not specifically worthy of discussion. Natasha Walter, author of Living Dolls: The Return of Sexism, shows a willingness to tackle the novel honestly, but her concerns lie not with the portrayal of sex, but with Grey's extreme wealth and James' inability to write. 'I tend to think that the submission isn’t wholly celebrated — it stems from abuse,' she says. This, at least, is a pertinent argument and one that Katie Roiphe glossed over. As much as Christian Grey is perfectly beautiful, generous, sensitive, funny, charming, intelligent, successful and adventurous, his desire to subjugate women is not listed as another of his virtues. His sadistic sexual practises, while deeply satisfying to Ana, are emblematic of his emotional and psychological traumas, and the one thing that stands in the way of his happiness.

Therefore, the sex becomes intrinsic to the developing power play of Christian and Ana's courtship, eventually culminating in the heroine's decision to abandon the relationship. This displays the struggle the hero has, as the reader witnesses him losing his ultimate objective, as we are supposed to believe that Ana is desirable. While EL James agrees with Walter it is apparent she either didn't understand her novel or was unable to demonstrate her intentions through narrative. 'Ana comes across as fairly submissive but she isn’t. She is actually the stronger of the two of them by far.' This would depend on a subjective definition of strength, but perhaps James views her heroine's selfless infatuation and constant sobbing as a form of empowerment. Nevertheless, over the course of the sequels Ana is rewarded with marriage and a pregnancy, thus achieving the aspiration of all females. Perhaps when James analysed her book as part of a conversation about sadomasochism of Woman's Hour she concluded that Ana was the stronger because she had no inner conflict of her own to resolve. Typical of romance fiction it is the hero with the personality defect to fix before a happy ending can be forged. Whereas the archetypal alpha males must learn to stop being arrogant, conceited, misogynistic, haunted by a ghost or ashamed of their supreme wealth, the heroine must be hamstrung by frizzy hair on sunny days just to keep from being annoyingly wonderful.

Despite judgements based on flimsy evidence, protestations spun from philosophical differences and a refusal to review the novel directly no one seems able to prove if Fifty Shades is anti-feminist or pro-feminist and if its popularity is a rejection of feminism or a celebration? Has the reaction to the popularity been confused by all this confusion? Dr. Drew Pinksy has been joined by others in finding the novel offensive and this appears to be a straightforward opinion to take, but surely this extends to the romance genre as a whole. Tales of solicititilation such as The Millionaire's Indecent Proposal are decidedly more sexist than Fifty Shades of Grey, which makes great efforts to show Ana refusing Christian's money, career assistance and expensive gifts. For whatever reason Roiphe's article was rejected, and it was rejected on many grounds, she should be credited for attempting to comprehend the reasons for the book sales and word-of-mouth that surrounds Fifty Shades, as it blossoms into a franchise involving movie adaptations and alarming merchandise. The counter-arguments offer little, preferring to instead close with a flippant dismissal of EL James' embarrassing lack of talent, perhaps choosing to assume that the best way to explain away the phenomenon of Fifty Shades of Grey is by assuming that millions of women are stupid.

Tuesday, 14 May 2013

“Freud would have probably died trying to deal with Fifty Shades”

Now that Bewildered Heart has completed reading Fifty Shades of Grey, after what might have been countless days of gormless gawping, in what ways should we expect the EL James abomination to affect us? Will our perception of the outside world be considerably altered? Will present and future relationships become stale and peaceful when held in comparison to Ana and Christian's or will fleeting fancies with weblogs such as Romance Novels for Feminists find previously unknown erotic depths and become dangerously sexual? Most worrying of all, perhaps, how can Bewildered Heart continue to find the same degree of satisfaction from reading Mills & Boons as we did through all those delightful years? Will Special Moments offer the perverse thrills to which we have recently grown accustomed? For those hiding under bed covers or attempting to wrap a silk tie around their own wrists, tremble no longer, because a swath of psychologists and opinionated laypeople have not been shy in volunteering their expertise on the damage that awaits us.

As witnessed numerous times before, there remains confusion as to whether reading romance fiction is harmful or beneficial to your psychological health, with viewpoints depending on religious background and book promotion. Fifty Shades has not only highlighted this argument, but amplified the potential risks or advantages. Idealising relationships, baby-making and alpha males is one thing, but glorifying sadomasochism, abuse and female subjugation is something entirely separate, and not necessarily accurate unless an expert bases their findings on haphazard estimations conjured from nothing. Speaking of which, Dr. Drew Pinksy is clearly uncomfortable with women using the Fifty Shades trilogy as a substitute for intimacy, or as a template for their own couplings. 'Maybe I have no business commenting on how women massage their fantasy life. Indeed I don't,' he begins perceptively, before continuing. 'But as I look at this as a clinician, the idea that women look at this relationship as anything other than absolute, categorical, profound pathology is more than I can imagine.' The limitations of Pinksy's imagination notwithstanding, there appears to be no evidence that women are seeing the novel's romance as anything other than fiction, but what sort of clinician would Dr. Drew be if he let that stop him?

'(Ana) is a woman who is naïve to (sadomasochism), and is manipulated and exploited by a man who has a severe personality disorder and a sex addiction who is violent with her, it is just too much to be understood.' The limitations of Pinksy's comprehension notwithstanding, his description of the book sounds a great deal more compelling than anything EL James was able to dream up. Still, in criticising the central concept of Fifty Shades Pinksy leaves out important plot points, such as Christian's handsomeness and wealth. An argument could also be made against the accusations of violence, as the first novel in the series contains no such instances, choosing instead to water down the hero's darker impulses until only rhythmic thrusts remain. In response to the standard defence that 'Swept-Away' fantasies are an innocuous hobby that allows women some escapism from daily drudgery, Pinksy appears to disagree. 'I would say that is a Stockholm Syndrome effect. The fantasy that you are in control when you are being manipulated and overpowered by someone, that you actually adopt their point of view and believe you are participating and controlling them is a complete fulfillment of a pathological fantasy.'

Dr. Drew might well be correct that a fantasy is a fantasy, but his conclusions lose their impact when considered against evidence. While Christian takes the view that the submissive is the one in control at no point is Ana genuinely empowered, instead a slave to her infatuation with a beautiful man. A much more controversial argument came from a Newsweek article by Katie Roiphe, which provoked a series of angry rebukes from feminists with internet connections. Despite this, Roiphe begins wisely enough, rejecting Grey as a proper sadist because he is, 'Solicitous and apologetic, always asking the heroine about every minute gradation of her feelings, and bringing her all kinds of creams and lotions to soothe her after spanking her.' The novel's appeal therefore is obvious, as it offers, 'Semi-pornographic glamour and the dangerous frisson of boundary crossing, while delivering reassuringly safe, old-fashioned romantic roles.' Yet, Roiphe contends, fantasies of female powerlessness are gaining in popularity during a time of women's sexual freedom and ascendency in the workplace. Is there a correlation between the decline of man in the real world and the rise of dominating rich men in romance fiction, and are there any statistics available that would disturb Dr. Drew even further?

'An analysis of 20 studies published in Psychology Today estimates that between 31 percent and 57 percent of women entertain fantasies where they are forced to have sex.' Theorists speculated on the reasons for this and concluded that women harboured such dreams because they were guilty and ashamed of claiming ownership for their own inclinations, but Roiphe finds this difficult to rationalise in the present day. Furthermore, Fifty Shades of Grey does not compare to the rape fantasies of the 1970s, but is Ana's form of passivity a rejection of feminism? 'The more theatrical fantasies of sexual surrender offer a release, a vacation, an escape from the dreariness and hard work of equality,' writes Roiphe. What marks this modern twist on sexual submission different from the likes of The Story of O is the inclusion of love as a motivation rather than an actual yearning to be bound and beaten. This allows Ana to, 'Indulge in the out-there fantasy of whipping and humiliation without actually taking responsibility for any off-kilter desires.' James uses this to appeal to our, 'Puritan past and our post-ironic present,' thus freeing Ana of judgement, while absolving her of the moral dilemmas necessary to reveal character. The story is simply too weakly told to offer political insight that would warrant closer scrutiny.

Writing in the New Yorker Daphne Merkin has suggested that, 'Equality between men and women takes a lot of work and may not be the surest route to sexual excitement.' Therefore feminism has no place in pornography, as male perverts have been saying for decades. The inherent troubles with Fifty Shades of Grey are glossed over by writers keen to focus their attention on other points as they use a famous title to lure in a larger readership. Those criticising Roiphe have pushed the notion that sex-positive feminism caters to all tastes, but this ignores Ana Steele's decision-making. As Dr. Drew noticed, without even reading the book, Ana is manipulated, bought and abused, as her innocence and obedience are fetishised. Her walking out at the novel's conclusion is undermined by her marrying Christian in Fifty Shades Darker, yet if the trilogy is the tale of Ana's maturity then meek subservience is a suitable starting point. Unfortunately for critics, their conclusions must be reached in spite of the source material, but analysing the possible reasoning of the readership does not offer understanding of the book. As a spiritual cousin of the equally atrocious Twilight, Fifty Shades suggests that women like classical romances with unashamedly idealised heroes, and obstacles such as vampirism and dominance need not be overcome, but instead happily shared.

Tuesday, 30 April 2013

“He doesn't sleep with anyone, although he has a few times with me”

As Fifty Shades of Grey reaches its empty promise of an ending with the supposedly stoic Ana Steele breaking down in tears for the umpteenth time the reader will be torn between thanking the heavens the ordeal is over and pondering the temptation of the sequels. Fifty Shades Darker and Fifty Shades Freed exist, and are even promoted within the first novel's pages, but there are enough warning signs in EL James' debut to crush the natural curiousity over what happens next. After all, nothing of consequence takes place in the initial five hundred pages, which seem determined to stall plot twists for no particular reason. When Bewildered Heart last took leave of Christian and Ana to file a blog report the characters were trapped in a peculiar status quo neither wanted nor wished to exit, due more to narrative requirements than personal integrity. Nevertheless, a handful of events followed, culminating in Ana's grand life decision to throw in the proverbial towel in her quest to turn a psychologically-twisted billionaire playboy into boyfriend material.

The entire plot can be encapsulated in a single sentence and probably should have been, but as the likes of J.K. Rowling and Stephenie Meyers have proved, why use one novel when several will maximise profits? Therefore, a critic must either subject themselves to the full trilogy or review the opening installment knowing two thirds of the tale are yet to be told. Such a critique might still have value had Fifty Shades of Grey told a self-contained story, and while Ana undertakes something approaching an emotional arc the book simply stops, rather than ending with any significance. Ana must sign a contract to be with Christian, even though she is free to renege on the agreement at any given moment, but she never puts pen to paper and eventually walks away. Christian cannot commit to a regular relationship or enjoy sex without involving his disturbing paraphilia, but the story's duration sees him carrying on a regular relationship without a nipple clamp in sight. As the explosive finale lurches into view the fate of Ana and Christian's eternal love hinges on his refusal to be touched on the chest and the mysteries of his birth mother and Mrs. Robinson, all issues that will surely be resolved when EL James sees fit.

Every potentially meaningful narrative turn leads to another life-affirming rut in a well-lit location, and momentous dramas such as meeting in-laws, graduating university, moving house or breaking up were never seriously dealt with due to Christian and Ana's unabashed lustful enthusiasm. However, after what seems like pages a momentary impasse is created through a thousand mile distance that not even Christian's impressive Popsicle can cover. Seeking answers to the intricate web of emotions deeply stirring in her stomach muscles, and receiving no help from the two other women living inside her mind, Ana jets off to sunny Georgia to see her mother and latest husband Bob. There she can relax, and do womanly things such as cooking, sunbathing and discussing boys. Her vacation is interrupted, thankfully, as Christian just happens to be staying in the same hotel where Ana and her mother are enjoying another round of cocktails. Naturally, Mrs. Steele is charmed by the hunky billionaire and his pathological need to track women down no matter how far they run from him. Ana is equally attracted to obsessive behaviour and immediately abandons her only real family. Shortly after two sex scenes a little more of Grey's enigma has been revealed with his stunning admission that he was born to a prostitute who had a penchant for a hard crystalline form of cocaine.

There seems no turning back from the implied importance of this biographical tidbit, but rather than dwell on substance the loved-up couple go gliding before finding their separate ways back to Seattle for the portentous showdown that does not actually matter. The atmosphere within Christian's apartment takes a dark turn, as James achieves the same subtle story-telling she would have showcased by breaking a pen over a piece of paper. One minute Ana rests her head on Christian's shoulder as he plays Bach on his piano and the next she is challenging him to spank her mercilessly as if to prove that is not acceptable. Such is the nature of the relationship between a temperamental psychopath and an idiot that this feels suitable for a conclusive detour. As it turns out Ana does not enjoy real pain and does not want to marry a man who enjoys beating her. With this life-changing epiphany forced into her inner dialogue she packs her things and waits patiently for Christian to write a cheque before storming out, back to her old life and back to being the weak-willed cry baby she wasn't before they had met. For their union to be successful Christian must recognise his demons and stop fighting them through the sexual degradation of women. As for Ana's journey from cliched female character in a romance novel to fulfilled wife of handsome tycoon she must not lose the passion and innocence that were never really at risk to begin with. Fortunately EL James has one thousand further pages to sort out these minor quibbles.

For Bewildered Heart there will be no additional reading, but instead a happy return to Mills & Boon where conceited CEOs of major corporations make their minds up relatively swiftly in matters of the heart. As for Fifty Shades of Grey there appears little to ruminate on. The book did indeed live up to the hype of being formulaic drivel with no redeeming features. Whether a thinly-veiled rewrite of Twilight or a contemporary misunderstanding of Tess of the d’Urbervilles its worldwide readership proves romance publishers are correct to push the timeless scenario of an arrogant alpha male seducing a swooning virgin to a backdrop of obscene wealth. What might have made Fifty Shades striking, and thus deserving of its astounding success, would have been the notion that James had taken archetypal characters and situations as far as they could go. Yet the novel consistently betrays its aspiration for subversive edge. Christian's sadomasochism is hardly explored, and the bondage scenes are tame compared to what is promised when Ana reads through her contract in chapter eleven. Nevertheless, this pulled punch seems minor when considered against the portrayals of hero and heroine and tedious lack of ambition shown in the story-telling.

For struggling authors of salacious daydreams there is now an opportunity to bring what James' novel should have been to a mainstream audience and the millions upon millions of dupes who fell for the word-of-mouth are owed something deserving of their devotion. Perhaps the journey of Fifty Shades from Twilight fan-fiction to standalone phenomenon suggests fans of vampire romance wanted more of the same, but with a little less of the Mormon propaganda. Christian Grey sates this desire, but in-keeping with Edward Cullen his dark and dangerous impulses are never a threat to the heroine, allowing him to manifest the idealised male while diluting the inner turmoil that might have strengthened him as a character. In both series, therefore, conflict is generated externally, despite the lessons of Secrets Uncovered. Twilight introduced a conveyor belt of malevolent vampires to chase Bella while Fifty Shades Darker feels it necessary to throw in philandering bosses, stalkers and helicopter sabotage to compensate for the obvious weakness in the core concept. Such seemingly irrelevant yet glaring flaws bode poorly for the future of the genre, but should serve as encouragement to those with their own idea for a high-stakes romance. If those aforementioned franchises were this popular despite being under-developed and badly-written imagine the fame and fortune awaiting an author capable of competence.

Saturday, 6 April 2013

"He likes his women sentient. He's probably not celibate then"

Fifty Shades of Grey weighs in at a daunting five hundred and six pages. The lettering is large and easily distinguishable even at an appropriately coy distance, yet the bombastic and inept prose style of author EL James will cause every reader, regardless of their obsession, to struggle their way through, questioning their commitment as often as the heroine flushes. The admittedly congruous pain of such an arduous slog could have been avoided had the novel any merits, but Fifty Shades of Grey is utterly without distinction. Now, there are numerous websites, newspapers, magazines and people standing by themselves at parties who are all too happy to discuss the book, and therefore Bewildered Heart, still grimly wading through turgidity with several hundred pages remaining, cannot simply regurgitate plot and glaring literary flaws, as it does with the majority of the Mills & Boon's it has reviewed. What little that can be added in way of explanation of James' enduring success seems worthless at this juncture also, and yet something must be written to account for the continued reading.

Therefore we shall attempt to highlight the positives in James' tome because, despite evidence to the contrary, there are strong ideas at the heart of the novel's concept, although James seems unaware of what they are. The tale of Ana and Christian rushes headily into the bashful glancing and blushing stage, with our aloof billionaire barely able to string a sentence together without grinning knowingly at the sexual connotations of something he didn't quite say. Our virginal, yet sexy, heroine seems equally incapable of performing tasks without deciphering the sexual connotations and reddening mercilessly, to the point where her ghostly complexion is replaced by a perpetual shade of crimson. Despite this, Mr. Grey is smitten. Even after several warnings from the man himself, her only friend Kate and assorted males Ana is too a prisoner to her carnal desires and soon, after a series of contrived meetings, a polite courtship begins. However, Christian is insistent that he be the only man to force himself on Ana and a drunken pass from token ethnic José only hurries the plot towards the losing of consciousness that inevitably leads to marriage. Before the reader can shout, 'Get on with it,' James has her characters in a helicopter on their way to Grey's luxurious bachelor pad, ensconced snugly inside a mountain carved into the form of his lop-sided smile.

Yet, as everyone already knows, Christian Grey isn't your average impossibly-beautiful twenty-seven year old self-made billionaire and with comical brevity his dark secrets are unravelled, inbetween lengthy bouts of plot-defying love-making. Christian asks Ana to become his submissive, the woman he keeps in a room at the top of his stairs, who dresses as he pleases, eats as he demands, shaves where he tells her and obeys unquestioningly his every whim. Ana's acquiescence is complicated by a mysterious locked door in Christian's luxurious duplex. Fortunately, any tension is immediately squandered as the door is opened shortly after Ana notices it. Inside what is aptly named the Red Room of Pain is an arsenal of torture devices, chains, hooks, ropes and a four-poster bed, because billionaire sadomasochism has decorum. As it transpires, Christian became a submissive to his adoptive mother's friend at the age of fifteen and after many years of corporal punishment has developed a taste for inflicting pain on others. Ana is horrified, yet naturally aroused, and tentatively agrees to read over one of the contracts Christian keeps permanently tucked into his jacket pocket.

Before soft and hard limits can be discussed there is the small matter of Ana's purity to deal with. Christian is unable to believe that Ana has amassed twenty-one years without a wealthy eccentric propositioning her, yet she is as untouched as he is perverse. Quickly he regains the icy demeanour he tends towards and breaks his two cardinal rules of never making love and never sharing a bed by gently making patient love and then sharing a bed of restful sleep. Ana has a man, somewhere to live, a car, a computer, a degree, a thriving sex-life and money, while Christian has been cured of his penchant for violence and has overcome his sleep disorder. Those assuming this to be a happy ending are best advised to gloss over the following three hundred pages. By that time nothing more has been resolved and no headway has been made into understanding Mr. Grey's enigma or Miss Steele's stupidity. Herein lies the inherent problems in James' story-telling. Fifty Shades of Grey is fantastical fairytale, ignoring reality and refusing to approach potentially compelling ideas, satisfied instead to trade on supposedly risqué sexual content for a gimmick.

The sex is poorly utilised, however, as James removes all darkness, brutality and threat in order to maintain the idealised fantasy of her world. She portrays Christian as impossible to love, due to his bedroom peccadilloes and aloof sensibility, but he is the finest slice of masculinity ever committed to page. He wants Ana, but only on his own terms and makes it clear he is unable to be the man she needs him to be. This core concept might have allowed for a searing morality tale, a powerful rite-of-passage or a emotionally-wrought love story, but the set-up is fallacious, as James cannot commit to unlikeable characters or even the slightest sense of danger. Christian is an intelligent, loving, sensitive, charming control freak who enjoys hurting women, even though he has never hurt a woman and does not like to. He says he cannot share a bed and yet does, sleeping better than when he's alone. His dysfunction is not debilitating, scary or painful, but rather a lively and worthwhile interest guaranteeing countless orgasms. Ana risks nothing by being with him and without knowing what she wants she stands to gain everything all women want which we assume she wants too, what with Ana being a woman.

Every romance begins with a couple arranging a compromise where both find mutual benefits from a relationship. Unlike the more honestly conventional Mills & Boon novels, Fifty Shades of Grey positions itself as the ultimate power struggle, involving sex as a visual metaphor for that confrontation. In this sense there is great promise in the novel's central conceit, but this is incompetently wasted, as has become custom in the romance genre. James strives for a powerful conflict that her plot is incapable of earning. The narrator is a morbidly embarrassed klutz who hates her appearance and seems to cope with the world by splitting herself into three distinct personalities, all of whom hate one another and indulge in a lifelong game of Schadenfreude. This is an obvious attempt to make her sympathetic, but instead results in a series of failed jokes. Nevertheless, these signs of deep psychological scarring remain the only indication that Ana has character.

All the reader is left with is what the reader came for in the first place, the sex. Christian's paraphilia for silk ties and riding crops is consistent with the flaws in his personality, creating the arc he must resolve for his happy ending. Yet due to the book's idealised wish-fulfillment the darker aspects of his sexuality turn out hugely gratifying for all involved, meaning the hero draws the heroine into his world rather than she draws him back to a satisfying equilibrium. Does James therefore make the argument that people should be more sexually adventurous, less inhibited and more honest with themselves about desire? If she does it appears to be a purely coincidental consequence of her predictable formula. Yet the impression is offered that Ana is empowered by what she is made to do and contented by the constant rushes of pleasure that crash over her like waves. This seems to be a delusional fantasy on the part of the author, as Ana's stereotypical depiction as an unworldly virgin allows for no insight into anything. Moving forward with dwindling optimism we note, with dismay, that there are many chapters remaining. Will we learn what secrets Christian hides behind his beautiful eyelashes and curly chest hair and more importantly, will they have any worthwhile effect on the story or Ana's philosophical musings?

Thursday, 28 February 2013

"A moppet-haired kid who likes impossibly sad music"

Any weblog on the internet that has ever thrown a blog party will be aware that Bewildered Heart has a tendency to arrive late, if at all, to such parties. Therefore it feels nothing short of appropriate to offer an in-depth critique of the opening three chapters of Fifty Shades of Grey by E.L. James, the cultural juggernaut that has radically and momentarily altered how people view sex, literature, book sales and traumatized tycoons. The novel begins on the rain-soaked highways leading to Seattle, Washington. Anastasia (Ana to her friends. Hi, Ana!) Steele is on her way to interview the enigmatic billionaire Christian Grey, founder and CEO of Grey Enterprises Holdings Inc, multinational conglomerate and maker of things. Ana is a bright, ambitious English major, studying the romantic classics James would be better off not bringing to the reader's mind. Her flatmate and best friend, Kate, was supposed to conduct the meeting herself, but has fallen foul of a narratively expedient sickness. Ana should be studying for finals, but how could she refuse this once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to sit down with a successful businessman who never grants audiences, only making the occasional exception for anyone who asks. Even though she has not asked, here she is anyhow, armed only with a Dictaphone, some notes, a tatty outfit and an endearingly feminine clumsiness. Ana is unschooled in cynicism and constantly berates herself for being unattractive, awkward and foolish. Despite this she remains irresistible to all men, with a smattering of fellow students yearning to review her dissertation, as it were, and several colleagues at the hardware store desperate to hammer some nails into her sideboard, again as it were.

Written in a more informal and conversational style than its template Ana's narration still shows glimpses of a disparate home-life that closely resembles that of Bella Swan, including an irresponsible and oft-married mother. Mostly, however, Ana frets about not fitting in and embarrassing herself in front of those with a firm understanding of their own identity. Without an image-conscious, insular high school setting Fifty Shades settles for extravagant wealth. Thus Ana finds herself intimidated by metallic architecture and women able to walk. She mentally prepares for the interview, going over Kate's questions in an incongruous scene when considered against what happens next. Shown into his provocatively enormous office Ana trips over her feet and hits the floor, but who is there to help her up but our novel's hero. Ana is instantly struck by Mr. Grey's youth, less than thirty, his physical beauty, physically beautiful, and his copper-coloured hair, coppery. Much like her spiritual predecessor detailed description proves too much for E.L. James, but the reader is left in no doubt that Grey is very gorgeous. Perpetually blushing, Ana begins to probe her subject, revealing that beneath the well-groomed surface lies a smug and arrogant control freak. Nevertheless, his personality does little to sway her strong attraction for him, suggesting Ana was paying attention when reading the novels of Jane Austen and the Brontë sisters.

Christian Grey is the embodiment of the modern Byronic hero, wealthy and powerful, dismissive and sexist, dark and good-looking, brooding and intense, mysterious and seemingly always running out of duct tape. Ana can do nothing in the force of raw masculinity but fall down, ask over-familiar questions and somehow beguile and unwittingly seduce, as she does with every man she meets. The next day Christian happens to be passing Ana's workplace and stops in to purchase some rope. They get to talking while shopping for questionable items and a photoshoot is arranged to accompany Kate's profile. The gang of possibly significant student characters descend on the most decadent hotel in the local area to snap some portraits and leap to some conclusions, before Christian invites Ana to drink hot beverages and swap biographical information at the most decadent café in the local area. At the coffee house we learn that Ana's favourite tea is Twining's English Breakfast, and logic dictates that this must surely become an important plot point later. Ana does not drink coffee and does not eat in front of men, but Christian enjoys coffee and is fond of blueberry muffins, yet despite their indubitably different lifestyles the pair seem smitten and determined to gaze longingly at one other whilst speaking in euphemisms. Briefly, Christian finds time to save Ana's life after another glaring moment of ungainliness and there the third chapter ends leaving the reader to hope something worthwhile will happen in the remaining three hundred pages.

After fifty pages of navel-gazing we have witnessed a relatively docile and old-fashioned courtship between an unworldly virgin and a ruthless tycoon who will stop at nothing to possess her, as politely as he is able to. The writing is clichéd, the characters are bland archetypes, the plot is predictable and had Mills & Boon been the publisher Ana would have accidentally stumbled upon an iron maiden locked inside a wardrobe by now. Naturally, Ana's infatuation with Christian Grey is purely physical, as the conflicts thrown in the way of their relationship are either emotional or cerebral. James handles this attraction with amateurish concision, making her leading man the embodiment of masculine perfection, yet she fails to properly foreshadow his dark side with satisfying menace. His haunted back-story and misogynistic need for dominance are portrayed with a slight, knowing curling of the lips. What little light this sheds on the hero it offers less on the heroine, as her decision-making is unthinking and trouble-free. This does not conjure a great deal of optimism for the moral dilemmas she will soon face, but it is safe to assume E.L. James will force as much inevitability into the forthcoming crux of the book's concept as she does in the opening scenes of mutual admiration.


Ana's naïvety and impassivity appear to be her defining characteristics and are surely appealing to experienced perfectionists with mother issues like Christian Grey, but this creates an uncomfortable confection combining romantic fairytale with erotic psychological drama. Modern Harlequin Romances such as The Billionaire's Housekeeper Mistress, Bedded at the Billionaire's Convenience and The Millionaire's Indecent Proposal each tread a similar line to Fifty Shades of Grey, suggesting the formula has its followers, but anyone paying even the remotest attention will have already understood that Christian Grey's desires run deeper than those of the idealised husband material found in the aforementioned novels. Thus the Fifty Shades trilogy is a heightened version of Solicititilation, with the heroine using her womanly patience and empathy to help a billionaire overcome his behaviour problems and teach him to stop treating her like a live-in prostitute.

Christian Grey is an exaggerated alpha male, still arrogant and obsessive, but now bringing his flaws into the bedroom for additional complications. James sets out to interlace her conventional Cinderella-style love story with elements of mystery-thrillers and Bildungsroman, exploring notions of conformity and female empowerment. At this early stage character motivation is undetermined, which gives the drama the illusion of compulsion, but what makes the novel a page-turner is symptomatic of poor writing. What does Christian Grey want with Anastasia, besides the obvious things, and why does he want those obvious things from her, besides the obvious reasons? Does he represent a threat to Ana's well-being, her morality and long-term life-goals? Furthermore, does Ana have objectives of her own, for a career, a family or a remote cabin in the woods to scrawl Neo-Luddist rhetoric? How much does she risk from entering into a relationship with this charismatic tyrant? Will she lose her friends, her degree, her sense of self or her sanity due to her love for a man, and how will she reconcile this against the lessons of her literary heroines? If she can have everything she wants without losing anything in return why would an author bother to tell her story?

Friday, 28 September 2012

" I don’t remember reading about nipple clamps in the Bible"

Selling studious criticism of Mills & Boon to devoted fans of Mills & Boon who are savvy with the internet has proved an arduous struggle for this Bewildered Heart weblog. The notion that romance novels are inherently dim-witted has been acknowledged by everyone except the authors of those books, and even they appear to be defending their work with the same lazy indifference to quality that they bring to their prose. Despite this, their enduring popularity remains undiminished. The fall in sales of chick-lit has been well-documented, but romance fiction is as profitable and newsworthy as ever, thanks largely to two phenomenal franchises, the twee teenage vampire swooning of Twilight and the decidedly less virtuous world of Fifty Shades. Sales of the first book, Fifty Shades of Grey, have reached demented new heights in success, out-selling Harry Potter and The Da Vinci Code within four months of release, with digital and print sales upwards of six million. The sequels, Darker and Freed, have similar, though less spectacular figures, suggesting either readers bought all three in one go, or read the first one and decided not to bother with the latter two. Is this the Lord of the Rings of literary sex?

The trilogy tells the sordid dating history of Anastasia Steele, a beautiful university graduate who attracts the attention of enigmatic twenty-something tycoon Christian Grey. He offers her the lucrative opportunity of being his mistress and she accepts for reasons that aren't explained satisfactorily. It is at this point that the book begins to twist its mundane, everyday scenario. Christian hides a dark secret and, furthermore, he is a sadomasochist with a penchant for whips, chains and possibly other torture devices. He is shocked, and no doubt a little perturbed at his lack of research, when he learns that Ana is a virgin and not particularly aroused by bondage gear. From there only two potential endings seem likely and one of those seems unlikely. Surprisingly, Ana leaves Christian at the end of the first book, frustrated that her mysterious owner hasn't overcome his deep-rooted psychological scarring and given her a hug. In the second part, Fifty Shades of Darker, Ana meets an enigmatic pharmaceutical CEO named Ezra Darker who offers her a small fortune to pretend to be his wife at a forthcoming family get-together while Fifty Shades of Freed introduces wealthy tree surgeon Cornelius Freed and the three men throw money at one another until Anna declares one of them the winner and marries him.

Within months of their release the books have become the literary sensation of the year, E.L. James is the must-have dinner party guest of the season and light violence has been added to everyone's sexual repertoire. Christian Grey is truly the popsicle flavour of the month. Even Hollywood has joined in, announcing plans for the film adaptation, with the likes of Emma Watson, Angelina Jolie, Ryan Gosling and 1980s Mickey Rourke all unrealistically linked to the roles. Some have hailed this as the summer of the bonkbuster, while others have coined the term 'Mummy Porn,' although this suggests something entirely different. These phrases do a disservice to this burgeoning subgenre, as well as sarcastic wits the world over, as James has hardly tapped into an until now unknown market. Her novels have sold astoundingly, as if every Mills & Boon fan stopped buying from the assortment of titles their favoured publisher proffered and instead plumped for the same book. Fifty Shades has not trounced the competition of the romance genre, it has simply become the romance genre.

In response to this consumerism, Mills & Boon has reacted by reissuing twelve of its most erotically-charged sadomasochistic novels, including Going Down and Cuffing Kate, but in doing so have they assumed the reason for E.L. James' recording-breaking trilogy is the sexual content and not the hackneyed archetypal characters, the hostile misogyny or the insipid writing? After all, Mills & Boon cornered the market on those years ago, and they have been running Spice, their explicit imprint, since 2008, and yet Fifty Shades was published by Random House, some company that could have been anybody. Notoriously Harlequin's product is not promoted for individual glory. Their books are on shelves for thirty days, but the evolution of technology has allowed contracted authors a shot at continuing relevance. Now all Mills & Boon books exist permanently through websites and as ebooks, and it is electronically that E.L. James found her audience. She began her career, as all modern authors do, penning Twilight fan fiction for an online forum where Twi-Hards reimagine their beloved heroes and heroines in a variety of situations. James quickly gained a following thanks to her eroticism and cliffhanger endings. Bella referred to Edward as Fifty and soon enough entirely original characters had developed, she a passive virgin and he a dominating billionaire, thus unlike anything in the history of romantic fiction.

The cynical attempts to cash-in on a hungry public desire may have misjudged their target audience as well as misunderstood the appeal of the Fifty Shades books, but anyone who has read, or attempted to read, E.L. James is at a loss to explain what her fans see in her. Reviews have been as negative as those aimed at Stephenie Meyer or the Sex and the City movies, suggesting a division between popular opinion and critical evaluation. Nevertheless, the reaction of Mills & Boon does not imply changes to their product or lessons learned from James' interpretation of modern romance. The issue of great significance at the heart of Fifty Shades is in marketing, and this is where Harlequin consistently betray their readers and authors as if as a matter of course. Fifty Shades of Grey may have been born from humble beginnings, but using the Twilight forums helped generated the sensational word-of-mouth that contributed to the impressive online sales that begat the print numbers. What followed was wholly predictable, as women rushed to buy the novels their colleagues, friends and over-confident strangers were all talking about. Many were titillated, but those expecting hardcore eroticism, lessons in sex toys or competent writing were disappointed. Briefly a healthy attitude towards sexuality was pushed into mainstream conversation, but Ana's virginity and Christian's unhealthy attitude towards sexuality soon put paid to that.

Nevertheless, Mills & Boon might hope to strike while the iron is hot, as any adventurous hero would insist, and seize this opening to update their brand. Fifty Shades of Grey is as unashamedly old-fashioned as Twilight, but the books are seen as the contemporary alternatives to Harlequin Romances it is socially acceptable to enjoy. With such a stigma attached there are obvious explanations for why the likes of Meyer and James have pitched their work elsewhere, yet the truth is Fifty Shades of Grey could have been published by Spice as The Billionaire's Blackmailed Mistress, few would have read it and the author would have been given a contract to dream up four new novels by the end of the year. If Mills & Boon has any intention of modernising its product, besides designing a website, here is as good a chance as they have ever been given. They invented this saturated market and then they saturated it. A new crowd of readers with plenty of money and little discernible taste has announced itself eager for a follow-up and all Harlequin can offer is shelf after shelf of drearily identical, colour-coordinated novels. Instead they need a single title, stacked artistically on its own table with a banner and a clever lighting arrangement, that tells the story of a penniless, yet likeable, virgin girl who meets a mysterious, brooding billionaire with a perverse ultimatum and also an estranged wife locked in the attic. Does anyone anywhere have anything like that lying around?